A longtime talent, Theo Rossi is having a definitive career moment. Across a string of standout roles (including The Saviors, Bruton, and now Aaron Harvey’s Come With Me) the actor is delivering extraordinary, deeply layered work that showcases the full depth of his nuanced range.
Much like The Saviors, Come With Me acts as a vital critique on the modern peril of societal rhetoric and the dangerous assumptions fed to us by an increasingly reactionary culture.
However, Director Aaron Harvey approaches this thematic landscape through a distinctly intimate lens, telling an unsettling story that will undoubtedly resonate with audiences on a visceral level.
To Close to Comfort
The narrative follows Simon Ward (Rossi), a man living a content life with his loving partner. That domestic tranquility is utterly shattered by a traumatic home invasion, flipping Simon’s world upside down. Suddenly, abstract fears morph into a very real, tangible danger and he decides to bear arms to feel safer.
It’s also just the beginning of occurrences that begin his mental buckling, with troubles at work and the loss of his best friend, he needs something to turn to.
In the fractured aftermath, Simon finds a strange solace in the voice of Dalton Kirby (a talk radio host played brilliantly by Rossi’s fellow Sons of Anarchy alum Ron Perlman). Marketing himself as an “unbiased and uncensored” purveyor of truth, Kirby’s toxic rhetoric becomes more than just an opinion to a desperate Simon; it becomes gospel. Sound familiar to anyone? And that’s where the horror really builds.
The Shared “Truth”
This represents a terrifying societal trap we see play out in real time today. There is an insidious power held by a magnetic voice, regardless of what they are actually selling. When that commentary happens to pierce a personal trauma you can latch onto, its significance grows exponentially. It’s got you. There’s a great scene at a party when some people mention Dalton Kirby and question anyone buying into him. You can see a wave of vulnerability cross over Rossi’s face as he vocally agrees with the others but battles his inner uncertainty and anger.
At its core, Come With Me is a chilling psychological thriller that holds a mirror up to the grim cycle of modern existential dread: fear breeds violence, and violence only feeds back into fear. As humans, we are fundamentally fragile, impressionable creatures. When the world feels hostile and terrifying on its own terms, submitting to an authoritative directive can offer a deeply alluring, if entirely toxic, sense of comfort.
Harvey’s film thrives in these unsettling psychological spaces, positioning Rossi as the ultimate, broken, man. The script, written by Jonathan Croom and Aaron Harvey tackles a subject that speaks volumes in our current landscape. This isn’t an easy watch, but it’s an important one.
Rossi’s powerhouse performance serves as the definitive emotional backbone of the film; utterly mesmerizing, and deeply thought-provoking. His inner turmoil is visually active and it keeps the audience feeling for him even as we see him fall.
The rest of the cast is also stellar: Kate French, Ron Perlman, Jay Huguley and Michael Sirow. The cinematography (by Ben Joyner) remains stark and grows increasingly bleak as our lead leans more into his paranoia until it’s darkened with violence.
Despite the narrative pushing into the uncomfortable territory, it remains a gripping, necessary look at how easily someone can fall under the power of suggestion when it is broadcasted to many. Even the phrase “land of the free, home of the brave” can be misguided and weaponized in a broken culture. And when you have someone already psychologically distraught, things can turn quickly.
Conclusion:
It’s a film that’s progression is predictable, but that doesn’t remove the effect. There is a strong narrative focus and it manages to keep you compelled while maintaining a sense of dissolution from our lead. This is a film that relies on a seemingly simple idea through a strongly written script and sharp character work, with a style that wraps you around its alluring, tragic, finger.
Come With Me will be released on September 4th.
Does content like this matter to you?
Become a Member and support film journalism. Unlock access to all of Film Inquiry`s great articles. Join a community of like-minded readers who are passionate about cinema – get access to our private members Network, give back to independent filmmakers, and more.
Join now!
