Atrocities taken from real human history haven’t always been a natural fit for the horror crowd. Although scary movies have long helped people process their feelings of fear, uncertainty, and grief in real time, filmmakers who are capable of thoughtfully translating serious historic trauma into satisfying works of genre entertainment remain remarkably rare today.
That’s what makes writer/director Taratoa Stappard’s stunning feature film debut, “Mārama,” feel so essential.
Exhibiting unique intelligence and soul, this first-time filmmaker just won top prize at the Seattle International Film Festival — with a singular gothic revenge nightmare rooted in the colonization and cultural theft inflicted upon the Māori people of Aotearoa/New Zealand in the mid-19th century. Drawing inspiration from his own family’s harrowing experience, as well as brutalities documented in the U.K. and New Zealand across decades, Stappard spins a mystery as miraculously sensitive as it is cathartic.
Set inside an especially appalling corner of Victorian England, where indigenous corpses were once treated like demented keepsakes for white explorers, “Mārama” is significantly more haunting than your average exploitation film. Stappard entices audiences with a sorrowful and fiercely empathetic period drama that follows its title character, Mārama (Ariāna Osborne), as she answers a cryptic invitation to visit a rural Yorkshire manor she may never escape. Also known as Mary Stevens, our displaced heroine was separated from her parents at birth. Now, the part-Māori woman believes her long-lost family might just be waiting with the stranger who abruptly summoned her to the British countryside.
Of course, by the time Mary arrives, the man who sent for her has suspiciously died. Hmm… Nevertheless, she’s determined to uncover not only what happened to her mother and father but what became of her twin sister, Emilia or Te Haeata (also Osborne). Well positioned in the pioneering and ornate drama of 1859, “Mārama” uses Mary to paint a ghostly portrait of the Aotearoa warriors whose identities were systematically stolen and fetishized by a pillaging empire. Property owner Nathaniel Cole (Toby Stephens) greets Mary with unsettling warmth, and flanked by his ward Ann (Evelyn Towersey), whose connection to the protagonist is a twist of its own, he quickly pressures Mary to stay on as staff.
Wandering the Cole estate halls as Ann’s reluctant new governess, with an eerie sense of both apprehension and morbid curiosity, Mary soon realizes her host’s fascination with her ancestry runs deeper and more sinister than he let on. Stappard, who spent much of his life in the U.K. while remaining closely connected to his Māori heritage, brings a fascinating complexity to that intersection — carefully using the perspectives of Mary, Cole, and the innocent Ann to frame his story’s cruel core beautifully. Deliberately slow but punctuated by elegant supernatural flourishes, the film is rhythmically confident without being too casual about its most graphic horrors, and Stappard smartly structures the suspense around Mary’s growing awareness that something about her host’s love for her people is very wrong.
Unflinching in its depiction of colonial violence and cultural appropriation, “Mārama” never mistakes the depiction of extreme suffering for profundity. Rather, it presents Stappard’s sobering dramatic concept like the work of a literary journalist reporting from especially abhorrent frontlines. It’s a hellscape that will be all too familiar to some viewers, and the writer/director is compassionate about that reality without softening the terror too much. Even bound by the rigid social confines of his period setting, Stappard understands that a modern horror movie cannot meaningfully interrogate historic oppression while forcing an underrepresented hero into an unworthy box. So, when Ann abruptly reveals the bizarre existence of a “wharenui” (a traditional Māori house) on the Cole property, Mary immediately questions that clearly invasive fascination with her lineage — and she mostly drives the pace from then on.
Intentional but rarely predictable, Stappard’s script doesn’t wonder whether evil exists at Mary’s godfarsaken new residence, so much as challenge her to uncover its full shape before she becoming a victim. That thrilling sharpness gives “Mārama” a propulsive haunted-house architecture, as terrifying visions of not only Emilia but other Māori women steadily flood Mary’s subconscious. Meanwhile, Cole’s quietly insidious plot unfolds around her with unnerving precision (although a handful of secondary characters sometimes swallow too much momentum), and that patience pays off enormously. Once tensions erupt between Mary, Cole, and his slimy associate Jack Fenton (Errol Shand), “Mārama” transforms into an act of retribution that’s actually capable of provoking cheers from the right audience.
What Mary endures throughout Stappard’s debut is unquestionably torturous, but the writer/director never seems to take pleasure in orchestrating her or any other Māori characters’ suffering. On the contrary, this uncannily wise filmmaker’s delicate touch underlines how vital authorial authenticity can be when engaging with genuine sociopolitical pain through fantasy storytelling. Osborne is similarly extraordinary, delivering the kind of breakout performance that could redefine the trajectory of her career if enough people see it. And Mary’s electric, palpably physical pursuit of justice becomes even more crucial in the final act, after a grotesque display of performative mockery toward Māori culture fractures the last remnants of civility present amid one of Cole’s lavish-yet-repulsive gatherings.
Stephens proves an equally essential scene partner as the primary “Mārama” villain, delivering the kind of refined but obviously bigotted antagonist that may always be destined to invite comparisons to “Django Unchained.” That’s oddly fitting for a film so deeply concerned with the violence of fetishization (particularly given how often Quentin Tarantino’s own revisionist genre work has sparked conversations around cultural exploitation and artistic entitlement). But Stappard’s relationship to “Mārama” never feels performative or voyeuristic, and Stephens weaponizes hatred only when he must.
What makes the actor’s work so unnerving is how sincerely Cole appears to view himself as an admirer, protector, even benefactor to the Māori people who have disappeared under his care. Stephens never plays a mustache-twirling sadist, instead carrying himself with the unbearable confidence of a man truly convinced that his version of abuse and even murder is civilized. Every generous gesture, every supposedly respectful question, every delicate expression of complete fixation becomes quietly infected by the growing understanding that Cole sees Māori humanity itself as something ornamental.
That queasy commingling of destruction and possession gives “Mārama” much of its lingering power, and by the time Stappard’s debut crescendos into one of the year’s so far most conceptually audacious finales, the filmmaker tackles the cinematic limits of monstrosity itself with shocking rigor. The true threat here isn’t found in gore or ghosts, but the instinct to consume while pretending to protect.
For all its real-world anguish and fictional dread, “Mārama” never collapses beneath the weight of its own seriousness. Stappard understands that catharsis matters too, and the film’s conclusion is exhilarating. In a cultural moment overwhelmed by more loss and death than any one film could ever fully metabolize, “Mārama” bears a striking clarity of purpose — suggesting the horror genre still possesses the ability to turn even a long-ago moment of righteous fury into communal confrontation and spiritual release.
Grade: A-
From Watermelon Pictures and Dark Sky Films, “Mārama” is now streaming through Fandango At Home and playing select U.S. theaters. It will open at SIFF Cinema Uptown on May 22.
Want to stay up to date on IndieWire’s film reviews and critical thoughts? Subscribe here to our newsletter, In Review by David Ehrlich, in which our Chief Film Critic and Head Reviews Editor rounds up the best new reviews and streaming picks along with some exclusive musings — all only available to subscribers.
