Near the end of “The Breadwinner,” there’s a close-up shot of a Sony-branded microphone that snaps the entire film into focus. Sony Pictures Entertainment produced this bizarre family comedy from director Eric Appel (“Weird: The Al Yankovic Story”) starring stand-up personality Nate Bargatze, of course. The studio also owns “Shark Tank,” the reality competition series that abruptly launches stay-at-home mom Katie Wilcox (Mandy Moore) to entrepreneurial stardom in the movie.
That lucky break means Katie’s cute but hapless husband, Nate Wilcox (Bargatze), suddenly has to step back from his role as Salesman of the Year at a local Toyota dealership, too. Then, over the next two-ish hours of mostly forgettable family hijinks, audiences must helplessly watch as Nate attempts to become a halfway good, full-time dad to his three kids… against… all… odds!! [Insert airhorn here.]
The gender politics in “The Breadwinner” aren’t exactly subtle, but almost nothing is in Sony’s aggressively manicured comedy about the American middle class today. Co-written by Bargatze and Dan Lagana, this strange yet intermittently hilarious misadventure actually works best when you stop resisting the eerie sense that you’ve wandered into a feature-length TV ad break — and start embracing the clearance-aisle philosophy that suggests any theatrical comedy is better than none at all.
“The Breadwinner” is truly decent compared to many mainstream releases coming out of the studio system right now, and if you’re willing to trade genuine cinematic sightseeing for a few broad laughs and a lot of product placement, then Sony has really got you covered. That’s not saying much for first-run offerings with both humor and heart, to be sure. But Appel’s contribution is a small win just the same.
In an era that’s made it nearly impossible for mid-budget comedies to thrive at the box office, there’s something oddly soothing about seeing “The Breadwinner” roll out nationwide. That victory gets undermined by the nakedness of Sony’s cross-promotional branding in the film: a business strategy that practically requires adult viewers to harbor an ironic, post-modern appetite for luminous KFC dinners, glistening bottles of Bud Light, and some suspiciously well-framed shots of the latest Apple Watch.
That harsh capitalist reality might tip the critical scales for some pickier cinephiles, who find themselves stuck between titles this weekend. But shiny commercial packaging shouldn’t move the needle much for friends and families who just want something to do together. Corporate-forward comedies probably won’t revive the old studio business model we knew so much as reshape the genre’s core viability in a rapidly evolving market. Here, that flattening extends to the film’s overly polished setting, where Bargatze and Lagana’s gleeful script unfolds against a wildly generic version of suburban Tennessee.
In hindsight, the sunny backdrop of the Wilcox family’s zany work-life saga may only be identifiable because it repeatedly mentions the NFL’s Tennessee Titans. The promise of winning coveted sports tickets and a fleeting moment of fame on the stadium’s jumbotron used to keep Nate engaged as an employee on the Toyota sales room floor. So, naturally, it’s not long after Katie takes off for two weeks of manufacturing tests at a plastic factory in South Korea (uh… yikes?!) that the shortcut-seeking Nate implements a similar reward system to get his girls through their daily chores, clubs, and school.
Eldest Gracie (Stella Grace Fitzgerald), middle kid Hadley (Birdie Borria), and youngest Sam (Charlotte Ann Tucker) don’t exactly break new ground as fictional siblings disappointed by their fish-out-of-water parent. But real adults, especially those who may be feeling anxious about where mainstream Hollywood stands currently, can find surprising comfort in this mostly optimistic fantasy. Yes, “The Breadwinner” is deeply imperfect. It’s also populated with enough solid jokes and familiar faces to suggest that the execs who are still financing these kinds of projects believe the mainstream comedy has a profitable future.
With just enough personality to distinguish itself from the endless churn of streaming sludge only claiming to deliver the same caliber of laughs online, Appel’s latest film tones down the surrealism at work in his earlier, far more outrageous Weird Al biopic from 2022. But the director’s second at-bat still feels like badly needed air for a part of the media ecosystem that’s been slowly suffocating for years.
Best known for the unhurried cadence of his stand-up comedy, Bargatze proves almost stunningly limited as a traditional screen actor. For the most part, Appel wisely avoids pushing Nate toward overly heightened emotional territory — instead, treating Bargatze’s deadpan confusion like its own immutable law of physics inside the silly world of “The Breadwinner.” Riffing on the same domestic themes as many of his live stage routines, Bargatze turns Nate into something like a live-action hybrid of Bob Belcher and Homer Simpson. He’s fundamentally kind, politically amorphous, and so domestically useless that when Katie asks whether Nate even knows what kind of laundry detergent they use, he replies, “It doesn’t matter. We probably have it at home.”
That punchline lands, and so do many others, as Bargatze’s understated delivery gives “The Breadwinner” an appealing anti-comic rhythm. As Nate transitions from vehicular hype-man to overwhelmed househusband, there’s a persistent sense that Bargatze the comedian is smarter and sharper than the baffled suburban dad he’s written to play — which makes the script’s overarching lack of tension even more peculiar given Lagana’s involvement. As showrunner on Netflix’s “American Vandal,” Lagana previously approached adolescence and cultural performance with a bolder satirical edge.
That said, Appel, Bargatze, and Lagana turn out to be surprisingly effective collaborators precisely because they seem to treat their movie’s shiny appearance and reputation-safe premise like a kind of nonverbal straight man. Appel injects giddy pockets of absurdism and sincerity into the script’s broadly commercial material, saving “The Breadwinner” from a sheen that might otherwise resemble the visual language once shared by studio comedies and broadcast commercials.
With a bright green lawn, tasteful interior design, a pricy renovation project, two cars (Toyotas, of course), and one income to support it all, the Wilcox family of five inhabits an intensely pro-capitalist version of the U.S. that companies, like special guest star Walmart, desperately want consumers to believe still exists. Despite that, Appel manages his movie’s tone with impressive dexterity — narrowly avoiding the lesser release that almost everything else about this film suggests.
Moore remains effortlessly personable as Katie, although her performance occasionally drifts into the uncanny territory of the aspirational matriarch she perfected on “This Is Us.” Katie remotely organizes her family’s schedule through a high-tech smart-home display that gives “The Breadwinner” some futuristic spin. But for the most part, Appel’s latest film feels assembled from prefab cultural memory. Think an IKEA showroom model, constructed by only slightly drunk employees.
Perhaps predictably, the cast’s strongest chemistry has little to do with the nuclear Wilcox clan. Bargatze comes more alive opposite his fellow comedians, who, appearing in various supporting roles, seem to understand the unusual frequency Appel is chasing better than the film’s star himself. Will Forte steals every scene he’s in as Keegan, an amateur roofer Katie initially hired as negotiation leverage — but who Nate accidentally adopts in a semi-intimate capacity best likened to a bipedal golden retriever.
Kumail Nanjiani weaponizes workplace desperation into vibrant tension as rival Toyota salesman Peyton, while Kate Berlant and Colin Jost elevate the surrounding community of neighborly archetypes through charisma alone. Even Zach Cherry squeezes plenty from his part as the dealership’s manager, who grows loudly resentful when Nate seems more emotionally invested in his biological children than coworkers.
Those side relationships are more convincing than the parent-kid dynamics at the film’s center, and while you know Nate should prioritize his wife and children, “The Breadwinner” is way more enjoyable when celebrity comedians drift into Bargataze’s sporadically quippy observations. That contradiction ultimately explains why this movie feels both hopeful and bleak as a modern-industry object.
Backed by too many sponsors to easily count, “The Breadwinner” illuminates a growing divide between moviegoers grateful for accessible family entertainment — and pop culture lovers increasingly wary of business infrastructure showing in every frame. To some, it’s just harmless product placement. But to others, it’s part of a slow-motion collapse into contemporary branded content: one that’s gradually proving new comedies, like “The Breadwinner,” can’t bring home the bacon on merit alone anymore.
Grade: C+
From Sony Pictures Releasing, “The Breadwinner” is in theaters Friday, May 29.
Want to stay up to date on IndieWire’s film reviews and critical thoughts? Subscribe here to our newsletter, In Review by David Ehrlich, in which our Chief Film Critic and Head Reviews Editor rounds up the best new reviews and streaming picks along with some exclusive musings — all only available to subscribers.
